Lot No. LOT-9664 · offered November 17, 2026
Crop EconomicsLot sheet
Saskatchewan Farmers Left $344 Million on the Table in 2024 by Sticking With Old Varieties
Saskatchewan growers left an estimated $344 million in 2024 gross revenue unrealized by planting older wheat, durum, pea and lentil varieties, University of Saskatchewan economists calculate.
Market notes
- Saskatchewan farmers potentially missed $344 million in 2024 gross revenue by not growing top-yielding varieties.
- Revenue gaps for established varieties like AAC Brandon and CDC Meadow ran $31 to $62 per acre.
- The most popular Saskatchewan yellow pea and red lentil varieties date from the 2000s.
- Even at a conservative 25% genetic-share assumption, the opportunity remained about $172 million.
- Follow-up research with Richard Gray, funded via the Agricultural Development Fund, will survey wheat producers and certified seed growers.

Saskatchewan farmers potentially missed out on $344 million in gross revenue in 2024 by not growing the highest-yielding varieties for their regions, according to University of Saskatchewan agricultural economists Nicholas Tyack and Anissa Collishaw, working with Kim Sanderson and Vitaliia Mishchenko.
The estimate covers four crops: spring wheat, durum, red lentils and yellow peas. The researchers compared varieties farmers actually grew with the top-yielding options recorded in their Saskatchewan crop insurance risk zones. Spring wheat accounted for approximately $176 million of the potential additional gross revenue, durum $110 million, yellow peas $30 million and red lentils $28 million.
The most striking detail sits in the adoption data. The province's most popular yellow pea and red lentil varieties date from the 2000s.
"I was seeing all this fantastic plant breeding innovation going on and new variety development," Tyack said. "Then I started looking at some of the adoption data, and I found that the most popular yellow pea and red lentil varieties are from the 2000s, when I was in high school."
Growers holding established varieties — AAC Brandon, AAC Transcend, CDC Maxim and CDC Meadow — faced estimated average revenue gaps of $31 to $62 per acre against the highest-performing varieties in their regions.
How solid are the numbers?
The figures are benchmarks, not bank statements. The researchers assumed genetics accounted for 50% of observed yield differences, with management, soil and other factors driving the rest. Cutting the genetic assumption to 25% still left an estimated opportunity of approximately $172 million.
"First of all, I would say this is a benchmark," Collishaw said. "I don't think we're arguing that this is a true counterfactual. We were just trying to get at what the magnitude might be."
The analysis does not fully account for harvestability, lodging, yield stability or whether the highest-yielding variety suits every farm.
"I wouldn't say that this is money that would have been in someone's pocket necessarily," she said. "But it gives us a place to start to say, is this even a problem? And we say, OK, yeah, these are big numbers."
Collishaw also flagged the thin research base. North American variety adoption has drawn far less study than in developing countries, where financial and resource constraints explain slower uptake.
"Even in a context like Saskatchewan or Manitoba, Alberta, where a lot of those constraints don't bind, you still see the same kind of question of why people aren't adopting," she said. "I think there's something more fundamental about how people are making decisions that we need to get to the root of."
Why don't growers switch?
Familiarity drives the pattern. Once a variety performs reliably, farmers stick with it, and the upfront cost of new seed is certain while its performance is not. Growers routinely invest in improved canola seed, Tyack noted, yet change cereals and pulse varieties far less often.
"So for [crops] like pea and lentil, it might make sense to not change their variety every year, but [it could be worth] thinking a bit more about switching the variety more frequently. Take a look at what's out there," he said.
The answer is not simply switching more often. It is identifying which improved genetics fit a specific farm.
What does local performance data show?
Variety performance varied widely across Saskatchewan. An excellent variety in one region was not necessarily the best elsewhere; established varieties such as Maxim and Meadow remained among the highest-yielding options in certain risk zones.
"There was a huge amount of heterogeneity," Collishaw said. "In a lot of cases, it's not clear that there is a top variety. It's really context-specific, conditions-specific, and it's a complicated choice to make."
That variation makes reliable regional information essential. Some Saskatchewan risk zones lack experimental variety trial sites, leaving farmers with little local performance data. Collishaw called for more localized, multi-year testing after registration to build confidence in new varieties.
Yield is not the only factor. Improved disease resistance, standability and other agronomic traits matter where Fusarium head blight, wheat midge, sawfly or root rot pressure crops.
What comes next?
The researchers suggest growers test on a small scale — a quarter section or half a quarter section — before making wholesale changes, comparing a promising variety against their established choice under their own conditions.
Tyack and Collishaw are now working with Richard Gray on follow-up research into adoption barriers. The Saskatchewan Wheat Development Commission and seed grower organizations fund the project through Saskatchewan's Agricultural Development Fund. It will survey wheat producers and certified seed growers on what prevents experimentation and how to make testing easier.
For Tyack, variety selection stands out because farmers control it directly, despite volatile input costs and grain markets. Faster adoption could also feed checkoff dollars back into crop research and breeding. The finalized research note is available through AgEcon Search, and the researchers can be reached at [email protected] and [email protected].
via seedworld.com (Source)
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Correspondent covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Agribusiness coverage for industry professionals at Agribusiness Wire.
529 articles
Also in the yard
- Slow Variety Adoption Cost Canadian Farmers $344 Million in 2024
- October 13, 2026 Opening Grain Prices Released by Saskatchewan Broadcaster CKRM
- SaskToday Posts Opening Grain Prices for September 23
- Closing Grain Report for Oct. 14, 2026 Lands at 620 CKRM
- Prairie Grain Markets Open Friday, September 25: CKRM Reports