Lot No. LOT-5397 · offered November 17, 2026
Trade & ExportsLot sheet
Seed Tariff Exemptions Won Since July, but ASTA Warns $45M Remains at Risk
ASTA won tariff exemptions for most planting seeds since July and blocked $45M in phytosanitary threats, but Sam Crowell warns regulators still discount seed trade economics.
Market notes
- Tariff exemptions secured since July cover most categories of imported planting seeds from the majority of global markets.
- ASTA says it blocked new phytosanitary requirements this year affecting more than $45 million in annual seed exports.
- Crowell cites cases where regulations target pests not seed-borne, or require seed health tests that do not yet exist.
- Individual affected seed markets can be worth only $300,000 to $3 million in imports, which regulators may treat as a rounding error.
- A new seed variety takes 10-15 years to develop, so current decisions shape what farmers plant in the 2030s.

Tariff exemptions secured since July now cover most categories of imported planting seeds from the majority of global markets — yet the U.S. seed industry says trade rules continue to threaten more than $45 million in annual seed exports through phytosanitary requirements alone.
That figure comes from ASTA, the American Seed Trade Association, which says it blocked new phytosanitary measures this year that could have hit the $45 million export stream. Sam Crowell, ASTA's vice president of science, trade and global affairs, laid out the stakes in an interview with Seed World published November 10.
"International seed movement is an essential part of how our industry delivers innovation to U.S. farmers," Crowell said, describing the core message ASTA pushed with U.S. government officials over 18 to 24 months of tariff fights. The industry won exemptions for most planting seed imports — but only after months of advocacy, and only for most, not all, categories and markets.
Where do phytosanitary rules miss the mark?
Crowell credits Dr. Martha Malapi, who leads ASTA's engagement on phytosanitary issues, with protecting millions of dollars in trade each time regulators move to update seed-movement procedures.
Some changes are warranted, he concedes: new pests and diseases emerge that genuinely require field controls. The problem is what comes next.
- Proposed regulations frequently target pests and diseases that are not seed-borne — they cannot be transmitted by seed at all.
- Some rules demand seed health tests that do not yet exist.
- Policies take effect without transition time, leaving companies unable to produce compliant seed.
- Certificate changes unrelated to safety cause shipments to stick at ports when regulatory and customs officials disagree.
Each of these failures carries a cost, and none of it shows up in the regulation itself.
Why does the economics get ignored?
The industry's diversity is its structural weakness in regulatory fights, Crowell said. Individual crop species or markets affected by a given measure can be small compared with other agricultural sectors.
He puts the trade-off in plain terms: a government official weighing a hypothetical pest against the loss of $300,000 to $3 million in imports may see the protective measure as worthwhile — "barely a rounding error" in market terms. The long-term consequences for agriculture, in his view, are far larger than that arithmetic suggests.
The takeaway is straightforward: small crops lose when regulators price risk only in import value.
How does the industry organize against barriers?
Seed companies tend to work crop by crop and country by country, and the patterns differ sharply across sectors:
- Turf grass exporters move large, containerized shipments with distinct logistics challenges.
- Vegetable and flower companies need small R&D plots across many countries.
- Row crop firms have historically fought regulatory barriers to innovative technologies.
ASTA instead targets root causes common to the whole industry. Its standing priorities are aligning intellectual property frameworks, biotechnology regulations, and phytosanitary regulations worldwide. Tariffs forced a pivot, and the association now treats them as an urgent addition to that list.
The approach is collective by design, because no single crop's market size commands regulatory attention on its own.
What happens next?
Crowell frames the timeline in breeding years: a new variety takes 10 to 15 years to develop, so decisions made now dictate what farmers plant in the 2030s.
He also notes a shift in the negotiating environment. Broad, multi-product trade talks are giving way to bilateral, country-by-country discussions, and officials increasingly ask for sector-specific input — including harder questions about how domestic industries benefit from investment at home.
"What will U.S. farmers grow ten years from now? How do we ensure that the U.S. continues to lead the world in agricultural innovation?" Crowell asked. "We don't have easy answers to the questions."
His caveat is the story in miniature: the tariff exemptions are real, the $45 million in blocked phytosanitary threats is real, but neither settles the underlying problem — regulators still weigh seed trade economics as a rounding error, and ASTA is asking the industry to join its strategic planning process before the 2030s crop mix is decided for it.
via seedworld.com (Source)
More from Olivia Hart
Show full bio
News editor covering technology and product news in Agribusiness coverage for industry professionals at Agribusiness Wire.
532 articles
Also in the yard
- Seed Industry Targets 10% of Global Seed Trade by 2035
- Global Seed Decisions Reach U.S. Farm Gates, SeedWorld Editorial Argues
- Seed industry tracks farm bill, trade moves — details remain scarce
- Seed companies absorb tariff pressure as input costs climb
- Trump victory puts new USDA seed framework in limbo