Lot No. LOT-7278 · offered November 19, 2026
Agricultural PolicyLot sheet
CFTC nominees draw warm Senate ag hearing, sharp Democratic questions
Two CFTC nominees faced a friendly Senate Agriculture Committee hearing, where Democrats pressed on prediction markets, Chicago staffing losses and the president's conflicts.
Market notes
- Four of the five CFTC commissioner seats have sat empty since President Trump took office; Chairman Michael Selig is the only commissioner to serve.
- Nathan Anonick, a Republican, and Matthew Rowland, a Democrat, appeared Tuesday before the Senate Agriculture Committee; Boozman called both "good people."
- The CLARITY Act, written to guide CFTC regulation of the digital asset spot market, did not pass the Senate.
- The CFTC's Chicago office has lost all its enforcement lawyers, and the commission has one commissioner in place.
- Sen. Ben Ray Luján warned nominees: "I understand that if you say too much Trump will pull your nominations."

By Marcus Bennett
Four of the five seats on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission have sat empty since President Trump took office. Chairman Michael Selig is the only commissioner to serve since then, and both the House and Senate agriculture committees have pressed the White House to fill all five slots.
Nathan Anonick grew up among farmers in North Carolina, and on Tuesday he sat before the Senate Agriculture Committee asking for one of them.
He came with Matthew Rowland, and the pairing is itself news. The law requires a mix of Republican and Democratic commissioners, so nominations normally arrive in twos. Anonick serves as a staff member of the Senate Agriculture Committee; Rowland is a CFTC lawyer detailed to the committee's Democratic staff.
Both men faced friendly questioning, but the questions from the minority side made clear that the real contest over the agency's authority arrives next year, when Democrats control Congress.
What does a pair of nominees accomplish?
Senate Agriculture Committee Chairman John Boozman, R-Ark., opened with the failure of the CLARITY Act, written to guide the commission in regulating the digital asset spot market, which did not pass the Senate.
He said: "the need for certainty in those markets remains significant. We are seeing an increasing number of Americans participating in digital asset markets, and without a comprehensive regulatory scheme, bad actors continue to go unchecked."
Ranking member Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., framed the stakes for a commission that began as a regulator of agricultural and mineral futures. It has, she said, "a fundamental responsibility to ensure that farmers, ranchers, and businesses can rely on fair, transparent, and well-functioning derivatives markets to manage risk."
She also catalogued the drift. Klobuchar said: "But these markets are always changing, and the CFTC we are discussing today already faces challenges that have evolved substantially since Chairman Selig's nomination hearing a year ago." That hearing came 12 months ago. Prediction markets, she said, have expanded dramatically.
The CFTC has asserted broad federal authority over a wide range of event contracts while federal courts reach differing conclusions about whether those products fall within the Commodity Exchange Act. Perpetual derivatives and contracts tied to individual stocks raise fresh questions about consumer protection.
Who decides what a prediction market is?
Both nominees told the committee they would not forget the dependence of farmers and ranchers on futures markets while they work through futures, cryptocurrency and prediction markets. Anonick cited his North Carolina farm upbringing; Rowland pointed to his work on crop insurance issues on Capitol Hill.
The sharper exchanges came from the other side of the aisle. Sen. Tina Smith, D-Minn., noted that Chairman Selig insists prediction markets fall under CFTC jurisdiction, while states and tribes argue those markets are gambling and should be regulated locally. Anonick called the jurisdiction question "a very charged emotional issue."
Smith replied: "I don't think this is an emotional issue. I think it is a legal issue. I think it is a core legal tenet that is laid out in the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, as well as the rights of states to regulate sports betting." Smith retires at the end of this Congress.
Staffing drew direct criticism. Rowland pressed for more personnel at the commission and noted that he belongs to a Treasury workers' union. Klobuchar said the CFTC's Chicago office has lost all its enforcement lawyers. Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith, R-Miss., said farmers in her state are worried about round-the-clock trading.
Asked about staffing at the agency, Anonick said he would "support an appropriately resourced commission," and Sen. Ben Ray Luján responded with a warning about the limits on what a nominee can say. Luján said: "I understand that if you say too much Trump will pull your nominations."
Sen. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., delivered the sharpest personal rebuke. Selig told Schiff he would be "a blank slate" on prediction markets and would follow what the courts say, Schiff said, but Selig "has been anything but a blank slate" since taking office.
Schiff said he does not know when he was so "blatantly deceived" by a nominee. Anonick said he wants to consult everyone involved in the jurisdiction issue. Schiff hoped there would not be a hearing at which he has to read his own testimony back to the nominee.
Sen. Raphael Warnock, D-Ga., raised conflicts of interest. He said he is concerned Trump is "enriching himself at the expense of the American people" because the CFTC has sued states to block enforcement efforts against companies in which a Trump son is invested. Anonick said the law should apply to everyone.
What does this change for growers?
Boozman told reporters after the hearing that the two nominees are "good people." He also said he hopes the CFTC nominees move with Greg Ibach, the nominee for agriculture undersecretary for trade and foreign agricultural affairs, and three nominees for the Farm Credit Administration board, in the next tranche to reach the Senate floor.
For growers and ranchers, the arithmetic is simpler than the hearing. A commission with four empty seats writes fewer rules for the hedging contracts they rely on, and a commission without enforcement lawyers in Chicago cannot police the firms that trade them.
The CLARITY Act does not exist as law, and the line between a federal prediction market and a state gambling license remains unsettled. What changes for growers is whether the contract they use to lock a price comes with an enforcement mechanism behind it, and that answer now waits on floor votes rather than on the agency itself.
via thefencepost.com (Source)
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering regulation, policy and their impact on Agribusiness coverage for industry professionals at Agribusiness Wire.
496 articles